Editorial for CCO '25 P4 - Restaurant Recommendation Rescue
Submitting an official solution before solving the problem yourself is a bannable offence.
Author:
Subtask 1
This subtask is intended to reward brute force solutions.
Subtask 2
This subtask is intended to reward solutions.
These sequences are related to an object in algebraic combinatorics called Raney sequences. In particular, the observations for this problem are precisely those used to give a combinatorial proof of the Lagrange Implicit Funtion Theorem.
A Raney sequence
for all
;
- all proper prefix sums
(
) are non-negative;
.
One possible solution is as follows: note that the form a tree
with vertices
, rooted at 1.
Now let
be a BFS ordering of the vertices of
, where
.
Then
is precisely the number of children nodes of
in
.
We will show one implication; the other implication is left as a (simple) exercise to the reader.
Let be a Raney sequence.
We will construct the desired tree
.
Initially, let
consist of a single vertex with label 1.
Let
be the largest label of a vertex in
, and let
.
- Assign vertex
children with labels
;
- Increment
by 1.
- If
, return to step (1);
- Otherwise, terminate.
As , it is clear that step (1) is always well-defined.
Furthermore, at the
th iteration, the number of vertices in the tree is
exactly
; as
for
, and vertices are numbered consecutively, there exists a vertex
with label
in our tree, so the next iteration is well-defined.
If , we get
, and so our algorithm
terminates, and
has exactly
vertices.
This leads to two possible solutions:
- check if each cylic shift is a Raney sequence; or
- for each cyclic shift, run the tree-building algorithm described above.
Subtask 3
By the previous lemma, the problem reduces to finding all cyclic shifts of an array that result in a Raney sequence.
Let
For , define
.
Let
be the smallest
that minimizes
, i.e.
.
It is clear that ,
so it suffices to show all proper prefixes have non-negative sum.
For
, we have
, hence
For , we have
, hence
We leave it as an exercise to the reader to show that all other indices
do not yield valid Raney sequences.
In particular, for
, one of the two previous inequalities will
be violated, hence the corresponding prefix will have a strictly negative sum.
Thus there is a unique cyclic shift that results in a Raney sequence,
and to compute , it suffices to find the minimum
that minimizes
.
This can be implemented in
time.
Subtask 4
Implement the previous subtask with a segment tree that stores the leftmost index of the minimum prefix sum.
In particular, the node corresponding to the interval should store:
: the sum
;
: the minimum prefix sum
; and
: the smallest index that achieves the minimum prefix sum.
Then to merge the nodes and
, note that:
;
and can be computed by comparing
to
.
Thus each query can be answered by querying , and each update implemented as two point update queries, giving an
solution.
Comments